Myanmar
https://raksha-anirveda.com/closeness-between-pakistan-and-myanmar-under-chinese-guidance-may-be-harmful-to-india/
Closeness Between Pakistan and Myanmar Under Chinese Guidance May be
Harmful to India
China is assisting Pakistan to
strengthen defence ties with Myanmar. Beijing wants to fulfil its agenda
through its proxy because there is an intense anti-China sentiment among the
people in Myanmar. Pakistan is delighted because Myanmar shares a border with
India through which Pakistan can infiltrate terrorists and supply weapons to
the insurgent groups in the North Eastern States. India needs to be cautious
By Jai Kumar Verma
December 10, 2022AdminForeign Affairs
The
military ties between the Pakistan army and Myanmar military junta are
increasing rapidly. China, which considers India as its prospective challenger,
is assisting Pakistan to strengthen defence cooperation with Myanmar. Pakistan,
which considers India as its enemy, is delighted to strengthen its defence ties
with the military junta of Myanmar as it feels that it has cultivated one more
friend in the region. Not only this Pakistan, which has waged a low-intensity
war against India, is also eager to inculcate friendship with the countries,
which share borders with India. Myanmar shares a land border of about 1600 km
with India, besides it, both countries also have a maritime boundary in the Bay
of Bengal. India’s four North Eastern States namely Arunachal Pradesh,
Nagaland, Manipur, and Mizoram share international borders with Myanmar. As
both countries have strong religious, linguistic, and ethnic ties hence there
is heavy traffic between both countries. The Inter Services Intelligence (ISI)
of Pakistan would try to exploit the traffic. There are reports that ISI was
funding, training, and supplying arms and ammunition to the insurgent groups of
North Eastern States. Not only this, ISI was also sending weapons and
infiltrating terrorists through these borders.
A Pakistani defence delegation
secretly visited the Myanmar defence industry complex near Yangon in October
and extended assistance in the maintenance of aircraft. Myanmar is using JF-17
jets, manufactured in China and assembled in Pakistan. These planes were
purchased from Pakistan
In October 2022, a high-level defence
delegation from Pakistan visited the Myanmar defence industry complex near
Yangon secretly. During the visit, the Pakistani delegation proposed that
Pakistan can extend assistance to the Myanmar army in the repair and
maintenance of aircraft. The visit of the Pakistani defence delegation was at
the behest of China as Myanmar is using JF-17 jets, which are manufactured in
China’s Chengdu Aerospace Cooperation and assembled in Pakistan Aeronautical
Complex although Islamabad claims that JF-17 was developed by both countries.
These planes were purchased from Pakistan. JF-17 has the capability of ground
attack as well as combat in the air. It can deliver bombs as well as
precision-guided munition such as smart bombs, smart munition and smart
weapons. These fighter planes suit Myanmar’s military regime as they have to
suppress indigenous dissension and agitations.
The visit of the defence delegation is
significant because, after the withdrawal of the US-led NATO troops from
Afghanistan, China is trying to enhance its influence in various countries,
especially in neighbouring countries, directly or through its proxies.
Pakistan’s police are also training
Myanmar police officers in mine disposal in Karachi. Eight officers of the Myanmar
police were trained during September 10-30 in Karachi in explosives and mine
disposal techniques.
A high-level defence delegation from
Pakistan also visited Myanmar in the first week of September 2021. The visit of
the delegation, headed by a brigadier, was not announced. The Pakistani
delegation reached Myanmar on September 1 and left the country on September 5
in 2021. During the visit, officers of both countries discussed the exchange of
advanced ordnance technology, aircraft repair and maintenance and naval
munitions. According to reports, now both countries are in the final stages of
discussion about the building of third-generation aircraft under licence.
After the withdrawal of the US-led NATO troops from
Afghanistan, China is trying to enhance its influence in various countries,
especially in neighbouring countries, directly or through its proxies
The relations between Pakistan and
Myanmar became tense when Myanmar evicted Rohingya Muslims forcibly. There are
reports that in 2018 Myanmar embassy in Pakistan spent a huge sum to provide
security to the embassy and its staff as there were reports that Islamic
extremists would be targeting Myanmar embassy personnel due to atrocities
committed on Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar. At that time, there were
demonstrations and protests in several cities of Pakistan against the Myanmar
government. Not only this, there were reports that ISI imparted weapon training
to Rohingya Muslims residing in Cox Bazar, Bangladesh. However, China which
wants to develop its influence in the world, especially in neighbouring
countries, pressed both countries to have cordial relations.
Min Aung Hlaing, a senior army general,
also visited Pakistan Aeronautical Complex in Kamra in 2015. Now Islamabad also
wants to inculcate friendly relations with Myanmar as Pakistan can export arms
and ammunition to Myanmar, which is facing several sanctions from the
democratic world.
China’s Special Envoy Sun Guoxiang also
visited Myanmar and met with senior military officials including General Min
Aung Hlaing. China and Pakistan both want to develop close relations with
military rulers as both these countries feel that the military would continue
ruling the country and democratic government would not come soon in Myanmar.
Hence Pakistan would enhance its defence ties with the military rulers of
Myanmar.
There is an intense anti-China feeling
among the masses in Myanmar hence Beijing wants that Islamabad imparts training
to Myanmar armed personnel. As Pakistan has also a large number of Chinese
weapons and platforms it can assist Myanmar in its maintenance, training, and
sale of spare parts. China is using Pakistan not only for arms export but also
wants to export other materials, which it is finding difficult to export due to
massive anti-China sentiments among the masses. Chinese state-owned companies
illicitly occupied the land of the farmers at the time of the implementation of
FDI in oil and gas projects in Myanmar. The oil and gas pipeline ran between
Kyauk Phyu in Rakhine state to Nam Kham, a town near China border. The Myanmar
masses feel that China is a supporter of military rulers hence the public has
attacked and destroyed the Chinese properties in Myanmar.
Pakistan’s police are training
Myanmar police officers in mine disposal in Karachi. Eight officers of the
Myanmar police were trained during September 10-30 in Karachi in explosives and
mine disposal techniques
China also does not want to export
armaments to Myanmar as it does not want to show that it is supporting the
military rulers who would be using these arms to suppress the democratic
forces. It would damage its international image.
There are reports that the Myanmar
military is planning to purchase 60- and 81-mm mortars, heavy machine guns and
M-79 grenade launchers, and would also acquire air-to-surface missiles from
Pakistan.
The report of the Stockholm
International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) mentioned that China’s share of
arms export in the world market has dwindled from 5.5 to 5.2 per cent but the
reality is that now China is exporting arms through its proxy Pakistan. In
2020, Indian customs officials on the basis of intelligence detained a ship,
which was coming from Jiangyin Port in China and was going to Karachi. The ship
was carrying an autoclave, which can be used to launch ballistic missiles.
The analysts claim that Pakistan at the
behest of China is focusing beyond the export of military hardware to Myanmar,
which is ruled by the military junta. The ISI also wants to use ports built by
China in Myanmar and it wants to infiltrate Islamic terrorists through Myanmar
as Indian security forces have tightened the security on Indo-Pakistan borders.
Pakistan is getting assistance from Aye Ne Win who is the grandson of General
Ne Win and is close to ISI and Myanmar army rulers. The construction of the
China-Myanmar Economic Corridor (CMEC), which links China with Myanmar, is
going on with good speed. Chinese can use the land route as well as the sea
route through the naval base Sittwe against India.
There are reports that the Myanmar
military is planning to purchase 60- and 81-mm mortars, heavy machine guns and
M-79 grenade launchers, and would also acquire air-to-surface missiles from
Pakistan
Although China considers the USA its
enemy number one, it also knows that India is its opponent in the region. It
wants to encircle India through its neighbours and hence it is rendering all
types of assistance including military hardware to Myanmar. Beijing is
exploiting its natural resources as well as its strategic location.
At present, the world is involved in
the Russia-Ukraine war, and China taking advantage of it, is assisting the
military rulers of Myanmar sometimes directly but most of the time through its
proxy i.e., Pakistan. However, anti-China sentiments are increasing in Myanmar
and once a democratic regime is established in the country people may boycott
not only China but Pakistan too.
However, India should be cautious as
ISI would use Myanmar for infiltrating terrorists and supplying arms and
ammunition to terrorist outfits operating in India. Delhi is able to control
several secessionist groups operating in the North Eastern States. ISI would
certainly try to support them so that law and order deteriorate in these
states. China, which is developing ports and other infrastructure in Myanmar,
may also use them against India if needed. At present, Indian security planners
are worried because of the nexus between China and Pakistan, the situation
would be more dangerous if Myanmar also joins China and Pakistan against India.
-The writer is a Delhi-based strategic analyst and
Life member of United Services Institute of India and member of Manohar
Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses. The views in the article
are solely the author’s.
Aviation & Defence Universe
WE JUST REPORT FACTS, WE DO NOT
CHANGE THEM
https://www.aviation-defence-universe.com/will-china-be-benefitted-by-the-recent-coup-in-myanmar/
Home › Spotlight › Will China be benefitted by the recent coup in Myanmar?
Will
China Be Benefitted By The Recent Coup In Myanmar?
- Or did China stage it remotely?
By Jai Kumar Verma
New Delhi. 15 February
2021. Pillars of democracy not only shook
but were swept away in the military tsunami of Myamnar. On 1st February 2021
Commander in Chief of Myanmar Army, General Min Aung Hlaing overthrew the
democratically elected civilian government through a bloodless coup. The
leaders of ruling National League for Democracy (NLD) including Nobel Laureate
Aung San Kyi and president of the country were arrested by the army which is
also known as Tatmadaw.
China which always maintained close
relations with the army generals of Myanmar and constantly supported the army
instead of democratic forces, has blocked the United Nations Security
Council (UNSC) resolution condemning the military coup in Myanmar.
The army deposed the government few
hours before the start of the new session of the parliament where NLD had a
massive majority. NLD won 396 seats out of 476 seats in the general elections
held in November 2020. The army declared emergency for a year as its protégé
Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) won only 33 seats. It was a great
debacle for the USDP as well as for the army. Both USDP and army alleged that
there were massive fraud in the voting and the voters list was fabricated.
Although the election commission rejected the allegations but USDP filed
several complaints to the election commission and a case was also filed in the
supreme court.
The army has wide powers under 2008
Constitution but still it became apprehensive of the rising popularity
of Suu Kyi. The military generals also became suspicious of the close contacts
established between Chinese government and Suu Kyi. The international media was
also pleading that General Min Aung Hlaing should be punished for causing
inhuman atrocities on Rohingya Muslims. There were also pressure from
international community to take back Rohingya Muslims. Although Suu Kyi
defended the army and stated that there were no brutalities but also agreed to
take back Rohingya Muslims. The army was against taking back of Rohingya
Muslims as the security forces allege that they are secessionists and fight for
carving out a separate homeland.
China, which is the closest ally of
Myanmar army, stated that imposing of sanctions and much international pressure
would be ineffectual. In past also China has defended Myanmar army in UN as
well as in other international forums, when the army was suppressing the
Rohingya Muslims. If the international community put rigorous sanctions, it
will benefit Beijing as the dependence of Myanmar will increase manifold in
China.
,
China is pressing that it is an
internal matter of Myanmar while the state controlled Chinese media is
projecting it as a ‘cabinet reshuffle’ however the public of Myanmar is
constantly demonstrating against the coup. The public is suspecting Chinese
hand behind the coup hence there were also demonstrations in front of Chinese
Embassy in Yangon.
The security forces used rubber
bullets on the peaceful demonstrators in Mawlamyine on 12 February while the
protesters also threw stones and water bottles on the security personnel. The
protesters were demanding release of Aung San Suu Kyi and restoration of
democracy. There were protests and demonstrations at several places in the
country as the public defied the ban on big gatherings. The military also
imposed night curfew in few cities. Government employees also joinined the
civil disobedience movement. About 40 police officers joined the protests in
Loikaw town. In a massive demonstration in Naypyidaw one woman received a
bullet injury and her condition is critical. Police detained about 80
demonstrators in Mandalay while about 200 doctors and medical staff also joined
protests. More than 500 government employees including security personnel
joined protests in Naypyidaw the capital of Myanmar and about 1,000 joined a
street protest at Thabyegon. The offices of NLD were raided and security forces
used excessive force against the peaceful demonstrators.
The rebellion is growing against the
military junta. Besides demonstrations public is also showing resentment
through banging of pots and honking of the car horns. The demonstrators
displayed placards and flashed “three finger defiance salute” which was first
showed by medical staff but soon adopted by other young demonstrators. The
military rulers also organised some pro-military demonstrations in few places
including Pathein, Ayeyarwady region.
There is strong reaction in the
democratic world. In his first public address on Myanmar, U.S. President Joe
Biden besides mentioning that the army should go back to barracks and democracy
should be restored also announced quite a few sanctions against the military
rulers of Myanmar. The military government is prevented from utilising USD 1
billion of Myanmar’s funds in U.S. The sanctions would be imposed on the
business interests of military rulers and their family members in U.S. The U.S.
State Department spokesperson mentioned that as protests are growing in Myanmar
it indicates that the public is against the coup and they should not resort to
violence against the peaceful demonstrators. Very soon U.S. would impose export
controls also. U.S. had levied sanctions against military rulers of Myanmar in
past, but the sanctions were removed in 2011. General Min Aung Hlaing and few
other military generals are already facing U.S. sanctions due to atrocities and
eviction of Rohingya Muslims. The U.S. also requested other U.N. members to
pressurise Myanmar military to restore the democracy in the country.
The Human Rights Council is also
working to establish human rights in Myanmar. The U.N.’s special rapporteur on
human rights situation in Myanmar also projected a dim picture as he mentioned
about the lethal force used by security forces against the peaceful protests in
the country. He also stated that security forces have obligation under
international law not to use excessive force against the demonstrators.
Not only China but other countries of
the region including Cambodia, Thailand and Philippines also mentioned it as an
“internal matter” of Myanmar. The Myanmar military overthrown the civilian
government just three weeks after the visit of Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi
to Myanmar. Wang Yi besides Suu Kyi also met military generals and the
possibility that the Chinese Foreign Minister gave the tacit go-ahead to
military general cannot be ruled out. China is not only the biggest supplier of
arms and ammunition to Myanmar but is also the leading foreign investor in the
country. China also needs help for its prime project “Belt and Road Initiative”
hence it will continue its support to coup leaders. China is investing in
several sectors including mining, oil and gas pipelines, hydropower, and other
infrastructure projects. The local population is against several projects hence
China may need army support to curb the local opposition. China is more
comfortable in dealing with army than civilian government and Pakistan is an
important example of it. As Pakistani masses are against the China Pakistan
Economic Corridor (CPEC) Pakistan army took over the project under its control
on behest of China.
The investment of western countries
is minimal in comparison of China.
The western countries have already
imposed sanctions on General Min Aung Hliang and other top military generals as
well as on other businesses as there are human right abuses. Hence the impact
of these sanctions on military leadership will not be much. In fact, these
sanctions will be counterproductive as because of these sanctions the military
leaders will become more dependent on China. At present the military especially
the young military officers were against the country’s dependence on China and
they wanted to import arms, ammunition and other articles from different
countries including India. Japan, Singapore, and other countries which also
invested heavily in Myanmar may put more restrictions which will also benefit
China. Myanmar army has also deep suspicion on China as in past it
clandestinely supported communist rebels and ethnic terrorist groups.
Besides economic interests China also
understands the strategic importance of Myanmar. China which is supplying
finished goods to the world is also eager to exploit the mineral resources of
Myanmar. China will develop China-Myanmar Economic Corridor which will give
access to Yunnan province of China in the Bay of Bengal.
The army generals are mentioning that
they will restore democracy after a year but in past they never fulfilled their
promise hence they cannot be trusted. The impact of the sanctions on military
rulers would be very less hence the world should adopt a balanced approach and
the problem can be resolved through persuasion, negotiations, and dialogue.
Stringent sanctions will be counterproductive, and it will benefit China. India
is pursuing a balanced policy and it will give a desired result in
future.
(Jai
Kumar Verma is a Delhi-based strategic analyst and member of United Services
Institute of India and Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses. The views in
the article are solely the author’s. He can be contacted at editor.adu@gmail.com)
https://www.aviation-defence-universe.com/will-china-be-benefitted-by-the-recent-coup-in-myanmar/
Home › Spotlight › Will China be benefitted by the recent coup in Myanmar?
Will
China Be Benefitted By The Recent Coup In Myanmar?
- Or did China stage it remotely?
By Jai Kumar Verma
New Delhi. 15 February
2021. Pillars of democracy not only shook
but were swept away in the military tsunami of Myamnar. On 1st February 2021
Commander in Chief of Myanmar Army, General Min Aung Hlaing overthrew the
democratically elected civilian government through a bloodless coup. The
leaders of ruling National League for Democracy (NLD) including Nobel Laureate
Aung San Kyi and president of the country were arrested by the army which is
also known as Tatmadaw.
China which always maintained close
relations with the army generals of Myanmar and constantly supported the army
instead of democratic forces, has blocked the United Nations Security
Council (UNSC) resolution condemning the military coup in Myanmar.
The army deposed the government few
hours before the start of the new session of the parliament where NLD had a
massive majority. NLD won 396 seats out of 476 seats in the general elections
held in November 2020. The army declared emergency for a year as its protégé
Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) won only 33 seats. It was a great
debacle for the USDP as well as for the army. Both USDP and army alleged that
there were massive fraud in the voting and the voters list was fabricated.
Although the election commission rejected the allegations but USDP filed
several complaints to the election commission and a case was also filed in the
supreme court.
The army has wide powers under 2008
Constitution but still it became apprehensive of the rising popularity
of Suu Kyi. The military generals also became suspicious of the close contacts
established between Chinese government and Suu Kyi. The international media was
also pleading that General Min Aung Hlaing should be punished for causing
inhuman atrocities on Rohingya Muslims. There were also pressure from
international community to take back Rohingya Muslims. Although Suu Kyi
defended the army and stated that there were no brutalities but also agreed to
take back Rohingya Muslims. The army was against taking back of Rohingya
Muslims as the security forces allege that they are secessionists and fight for
carving out a separate homeland.
China, which is the closest ally of
Myanmar army, stated that imposing of sanctions and much international pressure
would be ineffectual. In past also China has defended Myanmar army in UN as
well as in other international forums, when the army was suppressing the
Rohingya Muslims. If the international community put rigorous sanctions, it
will benefit Beijing as the dependence of Myanmar will increase manifold in
China.
,
China is pressing that it is an
internal matter of Myanmar while the state controlled Chinese media is
projecting it as a ‘cabinet reshuffle’ however the public of Myanmar is
constantly demonstrating against the coup. The public is suspecting Chinese
hand behind the coup hence there were also demonstrations in front of Chinese
Embassy in Yangon.
The security forces used rubber
bullets on the peaceful demonstrators in Mawlamyine on 12 February while the
protesters also threw stones and water bottles on the security personnel. The
protesters were demanding release of Aung San Suu Kyi and restoration of
democracy. There were protests and demonstrations at several places in the
country as the public defied the ban on big gatherings. The military also
imposed night curfew in few cities. Government employees also joinined the
civil disobedience movement. About 40 police officers joined the protests in
Loikaw town. In a massive demonstration in Naypyidaw one woman received a
bullet injury and her condition is critical. Police detained about 80
demonstrators in Mandalay while about 200 doctors and medical staff also joined
protests. More than 500 government employees including security personnel
joined protests in Naypyidaw the capital of Myanmar and about 1,000 joined a
street protest at Thabyegon. The offices of NLD were raided and security forces
used excessive force against the peaceful demonstrators.
The rebellion is growing against the
military junta. Besides demonstrations public is also showing resentment
through banging of pots and honking of the car horns. The demonstrators
displayed placards and flashed “three finger defiance salute” which was first
showed by medical staff but soon adopted by other young demonstrators. The
military rulers also organised some pro-military demonstrations in few places
including Pathein, Ayeyarwady region.
There is strong reaction in the
democratic world. In his first public address on Myanmar, U.S. President Joe
Biden besides mentioning that the army should go back to barracks and democracy
should be restored also announced quite a few sanctions against the military
rulers of Myanmar. The military government is prevented from utilising USD 1
billion of Myanmar’s funds in U.S. The sanctions would be imposed on the
business interests of military rulers and their family members in U.S. The U.S.
State Department spokesperson mentioned that as protests are growing in Myanmar
it indicates that the public is against the coup and they should not resort to
violence against the peaceful demonstrators. Very soon U.S. would impose export
controls also. U.S. had levied sanctions against military rulers of Myanmar in
past, but the sanctions were removed in 2011. General Min Aung Hlaing and few
other military generals are already facing U.S. sanctions due to atrocities and
eviction of Rohingya Muslims. The U.S. also requested other U.N. members to
pressurise Myanmar military to restore the democracy in the country.
The Human Rights Council is also
working to establish human rights in Myanmar. The U.N.’s special rapporteur on
human rights situation in Myanmar also projected a dim picture as he mentioned
about the lethal force used by security forces against the peaceful protests in
the country. He also stated that security forces have obligation under
international law not to use excessive force against the demonstrators.
Not only China but other countries of
the region including Cambodia, Thailand and Philippines also mentioned it as an
“internal matter” of Myanmar. The Myanmar military overthrown the civilian
government just three weeks after the visit of Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi
to Myanmar. Wang Yi besides Suu Kyi also met military generals and the
possibility that the Chinese Foreign Minister gave the tacit go-ahead to
military general cannot be ruled out. China is not only the biggest supplier of
arms and ammunition to Myanmar but is also the leading foreign investor in the
country. China also needs help for its prime project “Belt and Road Initiative”
hence it will continue its support to coup leaders. China is investing in
several sectors including mining, oil and gas pipelines, hydropower, and other
infrastructure projects. The local population is against several projects hence
China may need army support to curb the local opposition. China is more
comfortable in dealing with army than civilian government and Pakistan is an
important example of it. As Pakistani masses are against the China Pakistan
Economic Corridor (CPEC) Pakistan army took over the project under its control
on behest of China.
The investment of western countries
is minimal in comparison of China.
The western countries have already
imposed sanctions on General Min Aung Hliang and other top military generals as
well as on other businesses as there are human right abuses. Hence the impact
of these sanctions on military leadership will not be much. In fact, these
sanctions will be counterproductive as because of these sanctions the military
leaders will become more dependent on China. At present the military especially
the young military officers were against the country’s dependence on China and
they wanted to import arms, ammunition and other articles from different
countries including India. Japan, Singapore, and other countries which also
invested heavily in Myanmar may put more restrictions which will also benefit
China. Myanmar army has also deep suspicion on China as in past it
clandestinely supported communist rebels and ethnic terrorist groups.
Besides economic interests China also
understands the strategic importance of Myanmar. China which is supplying
finished goods to the world is also eager to exploit the mineral resources of
Myanmar. China will develop China-Myanmar Economic Corridor which will give
access to Yunnan province of China in the Bay of Bengal.
The army generals are mentioning that
they will restore democracy after a year but in past they never fulfilled their
promise hence they cannot be trusted. The impact of the sanctions on military
rulers would be very less hence the world should adopt a balanced approach and
the problem can be resolved through persuasion, negotiations, and dialogue.
Stringent sanctions will be counterproductive, and it will benefit China. India
is pursuing a balanced policy and it will give a desired result in
future.
(Jai Kumar Verma is a Delhi-based strategic analyst and member of United Services Institute of India and Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses. The views in the article are solely the author’s. He can be contacted at editor.adu@gmail.com)
Raksha ANIRVEDA
www.raksha-anirveda.com
Myanmar
Military Ruled the Country for Five Decades Stages Coup Once Again
An old adage is ‘History
repeats itself’ and it holds true in case of ruling in Myanmar. The Myanmar
Military which ruled the country for almost five decades once again staged a
coup while arresting all the civilian leaders, besides other stakeholders, in the
government
By Jai Kumar Verma
General Min
Aung Hlaing, Commander in Chief of powerful Myanmar army which is also known as
Tatmadaw staged a coup on February 1. The army took control of Myanmar,
civilian leadership including Aung San Suu Kyi, president Win Myint, all chief
ministers of ruling National League for Democracy (NLD) were taken into custody
at gun point. Party’s Central Executive Committee Members, legislators and
regional Cabinet members were also detained.</str
The army declared emergency
for a year after overthrowing the democratically elected government. The
civilian government was toppled hours before start of the session of newly
elected government. The NLD won 396 seats out of 476 seats in November 2020
elections while army backed Union Solidarity and Development Party (USDP) won
just 33 seats and it created the tension between military and the civilian
government. The performance of USDP deteriorated while NLD did better than 2015
elections. The army became suspicious because of rising popularity of NLD
especially of Aung San Suu Kyi.
The army ousted the
civilian government on February 1 so that the newly elected parliament does not
start its functions. Few hours after the coup, government-controlled television
broadcast that the power is transferred to Commander in Chief, Min Aung Hlaing
and Myint Swe will be the president of the country. Myint Swe is a former
general and was appointed as Vice President by the army in the previous
government.
The army
declared emergency for a year after overthrowing the democratically elected
government. The civilian government was toppled hours before start of the
session of newly elected government
The relations between
military and civilian government become tense as the Myanmar military was
uncomfortable because its proxy party USDP won very few seats while NLD got
landslide victory in November 2020 elections. It was the reason that both USDP
and military were alleging that there was massive fraud in the elections.
Nevertheless, Myanmar election commission made it clear that the elections were
free and fair and there was no evidence that the elections were rigged.
Both military and USDP were
demanding that there should be thorough investigation of mass voting fraud.
USDP members submitted several petitions mentioning about colossal
discrepancies in voters list before election commission as well as Supreme
Court. The petitioners also claimed that voters list was prepared during
Coronavirus pandemic hence it has several inconsistencies as at that time election
commission workers could not visit all the places. Secondly there were law and
order problems at few areas and the voting lists of those areas were also not
correct.
Courtesy: CFR
The United Nations and the
European Union mentioned that the military must respect the verdict of the
November elections. Nonetheless the army made it clear that the election
results were unacceptable because of massive fraud.
The 2008 Constitution gives
enormous powers to the military as it guarantees 25 per cent seats in
Parliament and also gives powerful ministries including home, defence, and
border affairs to the military. The 2008 Constitution which was prepared during
Junta rule permits the military to take power during emergency to stop the
disintegration of the country. In fact, the Constitution gives power to the
army to take over on flimsy grounds. The Constitution was framed in such a way
that it is exceedingly difficult for the civilian government to amend the
Constitution because the amendment in it requires 75 per cent votes in
Parliament while 25 per cent seats are controlled by the military.
The international community
criticised the military coup. The Indian Ministry of External Affairs (MEA)
issued a statement same day mentioning that “We have noted the developments in
Myanmar with deep concern. India has always been steadfast in its support to
the process of democratic transition in Myanmar. We believe that the rule of
law and the democratic process must be upheld. We are monitoring the situation
closely.” Jen Psaki, press secretary of White House, stated that “The United
States opposes any attempt to alter the outcome of recent elections or impede
Myanmar’s democratic transition and will take action against those responsible
if these steps are not reversed.”
The relations
between military and civilian government become tense as the Myanmar military
was uncomfortable because its proxy party USDP won very few seats while NLD got
landslide victory in November 2020 elections
US President Joe Biden in a
separate statement mentioned that the military takeover in Myanmar was a direct
assault on transition of democracy. The spokesman of United Nations Secretary
General while condemning the military coup in Myanmar mentioned that it was a
“serious blow to democratic reforms in Myanmar.” The military takeover was
condemned by several other world leaders too.
China has high stakes in
Myanmar as it has heavily invested in the country. Few analysts claim that
China is supporting the army as the young army and civilian officers want to
reduce Myanmar’s dependence on China. At present most of the weaponry of
Myanmar is supplied by China. The young officers want to divert the procurement
so that the country’s dependence on China is reduced. These officers want to
procure arms and ammunition from India too.
Myanmar watchers also claim
that the 64-year-old general was involved in corruption cases and in 2016 and
2017 there was crackdown on Rohingya Muslims and there were serious allegations
of murder, rape, looting by the army. The UN Human Rights Council mentioned
that as there were serious allegations on Myanmar army including Commander in
Chief General Min Aung Hlaing hence there should be investigation and general
should be prosecuted for genocide. General Min Aung Hlaing will complete 65
years in July and then he would be retired, as the chances of extension by NLD
government were remote, hence he overthrew the government so that he can
continue in power and he cannot be prosecuted.
Aung San Suu Kyi is
extremely popular in the country and hundreds of thousands of her followers
criticised the military takeover on the social media. However, there was no
major violence in the country and the army blocked roads, and the internet and
a message appeared that “server not found,” international and domestic TV
channels went off air and banks were closed. 24 ministers and their deputies
were removed and 11 ministers including health, interior, foreign affairs and
finance were appointed. Curfew was also imposed for some time.
The 75 years old
pro-democracy leader Suu Kyi was kept in detention for over 15 years between
1989 and 2010 and was given Nobel Peace Prize in 1991. The army is afraid of
her rising popularity as she was achieving a godlike status among the masses.
It is believed that she had large following in army also and several army
persons and their family members have voted in her favour otherwise NLD would
have not won with such a huge margin. In view of the extensive international
support and popularity of Suu Kyi, the military have to restore the democracy
in the country.
The
international community criticised the military coup. MEA issued a statement
same day mentioning that “We have noted the developments in Myanmar with deep concern.
India has always been steadfast in its support to the process of democratic
transition in Myanmar
It appears that General Min
Aung Hlaing will utilise one year time in strengthening the military supported
USDP. The military will also try to malign NLD and its leadership including Suu
Kyi. Although Suu Kyi supported the army internationally when it perpetrated
atrocities on minority Rohingya Muslims, but the army lost patience as the
popularity of Suu Kyi was increasing. As Suu Kyi is a strong-willed person she
will not cooperate with the army and army will have to restore the democracy.
Hence army’s overthrowing of the civilian government may prove to be a reckless
move under which the prestige of the nation is lowered without any gain.
-The writer is
a New Delhi-based strategic analyst and member of USI and IDSA. The views in
the article are solely of the writer and do not necessarily reflect the views
of Raksha Anirveda
Share this:
THE PIONEER
SOUTH ASIA MONITOR
Comments
Post a Comment